Adam Studziński | In Principle

A fraudulent transfer claim against a third party protects participants in commerce and helps combat reprehensible actions by debtors aimed at avoiding payment of their debts. Under a fraudulent transfer claim against a third party, a creditor affected by the debtor’s fraudulent behaviour may enforce a claim against assets that the debtor transferred to a third party.

Through a fraudulent transfer claim against a third party, a creditor impacted by the debtor’s dishonest behaviour can enforce its rights against property transferred by the debtor to a third party. This allows the creditor to challenge the effectiveness of a transaction carried out with a third party to the creditor’s detriment.

According to analysts, only 10% of startups are successful. Almost 90% of them fail—20% in their first year. On the record, such failures are often attributed to the founders’ failure to identify the customers’ needs, i.e. a real gap in the market, or blamed on competition and the uniqueness of the service or product. In less guarded moments, e.g. in online forums, much heavier accusations have been levelled against founders, such as the claim that most startups are designed to defraud investors or launder money.

Residential real estate prices in Poland have been rising steadily for many years. A house or apartment promised to be built or sold just a few months earlier may now have a market price much higher than on the date of signing of the preliminary contract. This may tempt some developers to renege on the final contract and instead sell the unit to another purchaser at a higher price. In such a case, what relief can the frustrated buyer obtain against the developer?

It is worthwhile for creditors to take part in litigation even if the outcome could go against them. This way, they can help prevent the court from issuing rulings sought by colluding debtors and their allies.

Dishonest debtors are increasingly daring to use court proceedings to fictitiously dispose of funds to pay their debts. They believe that if they obtain a final judgment that orders them, for example, to pay an amount to a third party, the creditor will not be able to contest the payment. But is the creditor completely defenceless? With this article, we are kicking off a series on what to pay attention to and how to react when a debtor initiates court proceedings that may render the debtor insolvent.

Acts by a debtor benefitting a third party—a family member entitled to maintenance—can violate the interests of other creditors and frustrate their ability to satisfy their claims from the debtor’s assets. This entitles creditors to seek legal protection under Art. 527–534 of the Polish Civil Code. A fraudulent transfer claim against a third party can be used to set aside a deed establishing a maintenance obligation.

A year has passed since a counterparty entered into an agreement with a third party preventing actual performance of a contract previously entered into with the counterparty. Thus the one-year time limit under Art. 59 of the Polish Civil Code has already expired. Is there still any chance to eliminate from legal circulation a fraudulent transaction that harms the creditor?

An investor and a contractor sign a construction contract. Before the contractor begins work, the investor disposes of valuable assets, from which the contractor could satisfy its claim for the fee, but the fee will not be due until completion of the work. In that situation, can the contractor take advantage of the broad protection of a fraudulent transfer claim against a third party?

With creditors in mind, we have launched a new special-interest service on our website, Creditor Protection, devoted entirely to what creditors can do when debtors unlawfully evade payment of their debts or performance of other obligations.

Pursuing claims and recovering debts is a legitimate right of every creditor, as is checking partners’ credibility. But this should be done wisely and prudently. Not only money is at stake, but also reputation, says Jarosław Szeląg, legal director and compliance officer at a financial institution operating in the automotive market.

Interview with Tomasz Mostowski, a licensed private investigator from the Legalplus detective agency